Could this be a step towards fighting abusive online activity?…

A new website based in Pakistan is working towards exposing online users who post comments or jokes with hateful, homophobic, racist or misogynistic content. (http://nafrataggregator.org)  People are encouraged to post pictures or screen shots of users and their comments in order to compile them in different categories from hate and misogyny to homophobia and even rape jokes among others. Upon checking out the site, you could conclude that some of the comments featured are not necessarily hateful or ill intentioned, but overall it is very well intentioned and could prove to be effective in the long term. Especially coming from a country considered quite conservative with many laws targeting homosexuality, it is interesting that the concept is utilised in Pakistan and shows positive progression.

A similar, perhaps more sophisticated example of a similar model is the tumblr page “Public Shaming” ( http://publicshaming.tumblr.com ) where more high profile online users are exposed for their twitter comments or public outbursts. Semi-famous actor Kal Penn of the ‘Harold and Kumar’ movies is featured for his advocacy of the City of NY’s ‘Stop, Question, Frisk Policy’ via Twitter. Penn, also followed it up with a response to one of his followers who highlighted the racist nature of the policy, stating that Blacks and Latinos are the ones committing the crimes and the profiling is justified. Also featured on the Tumblr site are people’s offensive Facebook responses and comments often with their full names and photos.

Overall, while these examples and other similar sites show a drop in the ocean of the abusive and unaccounted for comments that flood the internet forums and comment sections every day, I think that they are working towards making users more accountable for their actions and could contribute to some actually stopping and thinking before they type.

This contributes to the discussion of how the internet can be regulated by its users rather than necessarily from government forces and restrictions. Is this an effective way of making people more accountable for their words? Is it at least a step in the right direction? What more could be done to stop online abusive behaviour?

http://stream.aljazeera.com/story/201308122027-0022972

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Could this be a step towards fighting abusive online activity?…

  1. I hadn’t heard of the public shaming or the Pakistani website before but i think they are absolutely amazing. You see all over the net people posting hate comments and abusing others. Its evident every time you go on Facebook, twitter or YouTube. People think that because they are behind a keyboard they can say whatever they want without repercussions and remain anonymous. People need to start owning up for the actions on line, just like they would do (should do) in real life.

  2. http://nafrataggregator.org just blew my mind. The people behind it are tackling the issue head on, thank you for posting it. This is a really great post, the examples are great. Internet regulation is definitely necessary even though it seems impossible to execute. I believe people should be held accountable for all of their actions whether it be in person or online. People can’t be careless and expect to get away with online abuse.

  3. Public shaming is good for generating talk about the subject of bullying and hopfully more will be talking about it enough to eventually reach the people behind it. Putting the offences online is good for this but I think that the people behind it will keep doing it unless people they actually care about shame them. It’s just that I figure if these people have it in them to be so horrible to people in a public forum, they probably won’t mind if their deed gets more publicity. It will get people talking though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s